Why & Where To Eat Oysters In London
London’s relationship with oysters runs deep. They were sold cheaply on street corners at first, before becoming synonymous with luxury dining. Today, you still have the white-tablecloth institutions, where oysters are served simply with mignonette and Champagne, but a new wave of chefs and restaurateurs are adding bold dressings and matching them to different drinks. “We pair ours with mini martinis that complement the briny, salty flavour of the oysters beautifully,” says Madina Kazhimova, co-founder of Shoreditch’s Noisy Oyster.
A renewed focus on sourcing is also sparking new interest. According to Madina, “People are more curious about provenance and flavour, and oysters are a great way to experience both – different regions and waters produce very distinctive profiles.” She reckons they hit a few other trends too: “Oysters also fit well with the current dining culture of sharing plates, lighter dishes and enjoying a drink with something special but simple.” For Alex Busca – head chef of Milk Beach Soho – the upshot is that “people who order oysters feel like they’re part of a little club in the know”.
That little club is starting to get bigger as it opens its doors a little wider. At places like the Seafood Bar on Dean Street, Wright Brothers in Borough Market, Pearly Queen in Shoreditch and Seabird on the South Bank, oyster happy hours are drawing younger crowds and making the bivalves more accessible. You don’t need to splash on a full meal – a glass of wine and a couple of oysters can be the plan. If you end up ordering another round, well, so be it.
The format offers room for restaurants to play too. While others head into more experimental territory, the old guard of Bentley’s, Scott’s, Sweetings, Langan’s Brasserie and Wiltons continue to do what they do best. “We have specially trained shuckers on the bar who know their bivalves like the backs of their hands,” confirms Federico Fiorillo, head shucker at Bentley's, where quality and freshness remain the twin pillars of everything they do. Every oyster must taste clean and bright, just like they always have. The consumer just has to choose the origin of their oyster – whether they want one that’s plump and creamy or lean and minerally – and how to take it. Bentley’s owner Richard Corrigan always stays classic with just a squeeze of lemon and a twist of black pepper.
But for anyone who finds a raw oyster is intimidating, there are now alternatives. “Grilling them, dressing them or pairing them with unexpected flavours allows people to experience them in a more relaxed way,” says Madina. “Our seasonal bloody mary oyster is especially popular and pairs perfectly with a Guinness or our Michelada.” Noisy Oyster also does an oyster nugget with parmesan mayo, paprika and Oscietra black caviar. Alex Webb of Wimbledon’s Orion is another proponent of cooked oysters: “Our chefs can layer flavours – heat, acid, fat and texture – in ways raw oysters don’t always allow.” At Borough’s Pyro, you might find oyster saganaki, toasted bread and fennel; or you could try oysters topped with champagne, sour cream, green strawberry and dulse at Kitchen Table in Fitzrovia. For this year’s British Pie Week, the Mayfair Chippy even served a steak and oyster pie topped with a deep-fried oyster.
The takeaway for London’s diners is clear: no excuses. Order the oysters.
THE BEST PLACES TO EAT OYSTERS IN LONDON
Bentley’s Oyster Bar & Grill
The blueprint. Still one of the best places in the city to eat oysters as they should be – impeccably sourced and served on ice.
Visit Bentleys.org
J Sheekey
At this Covent Garden institution, oysters become theatre. Order a dozen, add a martini and enjoy the show.
Visit J-Sheekey.co.uk
The Oystermen Seafood Bar & Kitchen
Take your pick from raw, dressed and cooked oysters at a place that has ditched the white tablecloths but retained the old-school hospitality.
Visit OysterMen.co.uk
Wright Brothers Borough Market
The sourcing’s excellent, so is the atmosphere, but the happy hour is the biggest part of the draw.
Visit TheWrightBrothers.co.uk
Scott’s
This is the place for oysters with a side of Mayfair gloss. Expensive, but always good.
Visit Scotts-Mayfair.com
Darby’s
Sit at the counter, order a Guinness and enjoy this love letter to the classic oyster bars of New York.
Visit Darbys-London.com
The Mayfair Chippy
Its well-sourced oysters are a perfect starter before the eponymous main event.
Visit MayfairChippy.com
Noisy Oyster
Fun, loud and a little irreverent, this is a buzzy new addition that draws a fashionable crowd.
Visit NoisyOysterLondon.co.uk
DISCLAIMER: We endeavour to always credit the correct original source of every image we use. If you think a credit may be incorrect, please contact us at [email protected].